Tuesday, September 29, 2026

True Crime and Punishment: Truman Capote and "In Cold Blood"

 

In the wee hours of November 15, 1959, two men broke into the home of the Clutters, a well-to-do farming family in rural Kansas. They were searching for a safe rumored to contain upwards of $10,000. When the safe failed to turn up — Mr. Clutter did all transactions by check — the family were all executed by single shotgun blasts to the head. The murderers made off with little more than about $40 cash, a radio and some binoculars.

The resulting media frenzy attracted the attention of one Truman Capote, accomplished author, soft-spoken dandy and self-aggrandizing fixture of the New York City social scene. Deciding apparently on a whim that he wanted to write about the Clutter family murders, he traveled to Kansas with his friend Harper Lee (yes, that one) in tow. After the killers were caught, he developed a rapport with them, becoming in effect their only friend in the world, for the sole purpose of getting them to tell him what happened that chilly night in 1959. The resulting book, In Cold Blood, published in 1966 (a year after the killers were executed on the same night in April 1965) was a smash hit, more or less inventing the modern true crime genre. Fast forward 55 years later and white women thirst over notorious serial killer Ted Bundy because of a hot actor who played him on Netflix. How did we get here?

In Cold Blood, 1967, d. Richard Brooks

We can sort of catch a glimpse of the real nature of true crime in Capote, Bennett Miller's 2005 biopic about the man during his time writing In Cold Blood. Played by the late, great Philip Seymour Hoffman, Capote in this film is profoundly selfish and egotistical, at one point saying over the phone "sometimes I can't breathe when I think about how great my book is going to be." He hires a better lawyer for the Clutters' killers, which he openly admits (to everyone except the killers) is so they stay alive to help with his book. He spends years gradually pumping them for information, particularly Perry Smith, the quiet, more sensitive of the murderous duo who nevertheless committed at least two of the murders if not all four, in a self-admitted rage. Capote spends the whole film talking up his book; there is some light feinting towards finding the death penalty as an injustice, but as Harper Lee correctly points out, he needed Smith and Dick Hickock to die for his book.

I'm getting ahead of myself here, maybe. So what is true crime and why does it matter? True crime, as a literary and documentary genre, is nonfiction about, well, real crimes and atrocities, particularly murders — the more shocking and grotesque, the better. The genre ranges from books (In Cold Blood, obviously, but also Helter Skelter, about the Manson murders) to documentary film (Conversations With A Killer: The Ted Bundy Tapes, Bowling for Columbine) to television series (America's Most Wanted, Making a Murderer, and Court TV legiterally rebranding itself as True Crime Network) to podcasts (the unfortunately but tellingly-named Crime Junkie and My Favorite Murder) to trashy internet content (listicles, or YouTubers like PlaguedMoth, which I do not recommend you look up) and even parodies. While there is often some attempt at treating the crimes and their victims with some sensitivity, many more choose to go with lurid sensationalism. They don't give a shit about the victims. They don't give a shit about the victims' families. They arguably don't even give a shit about the killers as human beings who committed horrible crimes for one reason or another, but as (often sexual) objects that generate Content. The murders are Content. The victims are Content. The often grossly incompetent police work is Content. Grist for the mill.

Capote, 2005, d. Bennett Miller

The true crime industry exists to shock and titillate, to capitalize on society's growing paranoia and societal alienation by convincing a bloodthirsty audience that yes, the world is a dangerous, violent place, and you can only protect yourself by treating everyone you meet as a potential murderer, rapist, and/or cannibal, especially if they're darker than a paper bag and wearing a courier uniform. Truman Capote positioned himself as this high and mighty literary genius who would expose to the world the dark underbelly of America, where even the most idyllic, wholesome 1950s small town Mom and Pop and Kiddos can become victims of howling lunatics who haunt the highways looking for flesh. What separates him from the ghouls behind, say, the YouTube channel Misery Machine?

This, then, is the real evil of true crime: for every story that sheds new light on an unsolved crime, leading to killers finally getting caught or crucial clues being uncovered, there's a dozen more that cater to an audience that fancies themselves detectives. "Join me on my makeup routine as we talk about the Boise Dick Splitter" no! fuck you! It's gossip, pornoviolence, and surveillance state propaganda all in one, all in pursuit of clicks and ad money. That's not even getting into the phenomenon of Internet Newspeak, where people on social media self-censor out of fear of being demonetized or deprioritized by the almighty algo, which is how we get documentaries about "the mustache man and how he unalived a bunch of protected people." Fuck you! This is hell! We live in hell!

Truman Capote, beaming his genius
directly into your brain 

This originally started, I guess, as a review of sorts of the In Cold Blood film adaptation (masterfully directed by Richard Brooks, a very early New Hollywood neo-noir that was deliberately shot in the black and white of golden age noir film) and of Capote. I'd thought to myself that I wanted to sort of touch on true crime as a genre but focus more on the films as technical and acting showcases (Hoffman so closely embodies the real Capote you almost forget that he was also in the Hunger Games movies.) But as I watched the films, I grew to despise the real Capote as a person; while the lawyer thing was invented for the movie, it remains true that he had a vested interest in keeping Smith and Hickock alive for his book. In a very real sense, his book is Capote inserting himself into a case that had nothing to do with him; he saw in the newspaper a short article about a whole family being massacred and immediately decided that's what he wanted his next book to be about, dropping his then-current project and gallivanting off to Kansas. For the two surviving adult children of the Clutter family, what happened was a devastating, horrifying loss; for the town it happened in, it was a nightmare scenario that kept everyone awake at night, wondering who might come knocking next. For Truman Capote, it was Content.

Truman Capote never finished another book after In Cold Blood. He would later speak often about how writing it seemed to destroy him, in a way. He spent five long years researching and writing it, and finally getting it done left him broken. He wound up burning most of his bridges with the New York City social scene and replacing them with booze and pills. He died of liver disease in 1984.

No comments:

Post a Comment